EN

Three-phase transformers: connections and vector groups

Star, delta and zigzag, the clock number and which transformers can be paralleled

1. The three winding connections

Each side of a three-phase transformer has three windings, one per limb, connected in one of these three ways:

ConnectionVoltage across each windingCurrent in each windingNeutral
Star\(U_L/\sqrt3\)\(I_L\)Yes
Delta\(U_L\)\(I_L/\sqrt3\)No
Zigzag\(U_L/3\) across each half-winding\(I_L\)Yes

\(U_L\) and \(I_L\) are the line-to-line voltage and the line current. In a zigzag the two half-windings of a phase are 60° apart and their sum is \(\sqrt3\) times each one; for the same voltage it needs 15.5 % more turns than a star (\(2/\sqrt3 = 1.155\)).

The voltage ratio is the ratio of line voltages, \(m = U_{1L}/U_{2L}\), but the turns ratio depends on the connections:

\[ \text{Yy, Dd: } \frac{N_1}{N_2} = \frac{U_{1L}}{U_{2L}} \]
\[ \text{Dy: } \frac{N_1}{N_2} = \frac{\sqrt3\,U_{1L}}{U_{2L}} \]
\[ \text{Yd: } \frac{N_1}{N_2} = \frac{U_{1L}}{\sqrt3\,U_{2L}} \]
Example. A 20,000 / 420 V Dyn11 has 20,000 V across each HV winding and \(420/\sqrt3 = 242.5\) V across each LV winding: the turns ratio is \(20\,000/242.5 = 82.5\), not \(20\,000/420 = 47.6\).

2. How it is named: the vector group

The designation, according to IEC 60076-1, combines the HV connection in capitals (Y, D, Z), the LV connection in lower case (y, d, z), an N or n if the neutral is brought out, and the clock number. For example:

Terminals are marked 1U, 1V, 1W on the HV side and 2U, 2V, 2W on the LV side, with 1N or 2N for the neutral. The ends of each winding are 1U1 and 1U2, 2U1 and 2U2… Older nameplates use A, B, C and a, b, c.

3. The clock number

LV voltages are not always in phase with HV voltages: depending on the connections, they lag by a multiple of 30°. The clock number says how many: the 1U voltage is drawn at 12 o'clock and the 2U voltage falls on the hour given by the number.

\[ \varphi = n \cdot 30^\circ \qquad \text{(LV lag behind HV)} \]

Dyn11 has the LV lagging by 330°, which is the same as leading by 30°; Dyn5, lagging by 150°. Delta and zigzag shift 30° with respect to star, so Yy, Dd and Dz give even numbers, and Dy, Yd and Yz odd ones. Reversing the ends of the LV windings adds 6 (180°): Yy0 becomes Yy6.

NumberPhase shiftStandard groups
00°Yy0, Dd0, Dz0
6180°Yy6, Dd6, Dz6
5150°Dy5, Yd5, Yz5
11330°Dy11, Yd11, Yz11
1 and 730° and 210°Dy1, Yd1, Yz1 · Dy7, Yd7, Yz7
2, 4, 8 and 1060° to 300°Dd2, Dd4, Dd8, Dd10 · Dz2, Dz4, Dz8, Dz10

The first four are the usual ones. In practice almost all distribution transformers are Dyn11, Dyn5, Yyn0 or Yzn11.

4. Vector group explorer

Choose the connections and the clock number: the connection diagram is drawn, with a dot at the start of each winding, together with the clock diagram, showing the HV triangle (1U at 12) and the LV one. Below are the voltages to measure in the test of section 7.

V
V
V

5. Most common connections and what they are for

GroupUseWhy
Dyn11 (or Dyn5)LV distribution, the most commonThe neutral can carry fully unbalanced load; the HV delta traps third harmonics and spreads the unbalance over the three phases of the network.
Yyn0Small distribution transformers, older unitsCheap, with star-connected HV insulation, but the LV neutral can only take little load (usually limited to 10 % of rated): with single-phase load the zero-sequence flux shifts the neutral. For more load it needs a delta tertiary.
Yzn11 (or Yzn5)Small rural distribution with a lot of single-phase loadThe zigzag spreads the load of each phase over two limbs and the neutral can take full load, at the cost of 15.5 % more LV copper.
YNd11 (or YNd5)Generator step-up and network transformersDelta on the generator side; HV neutral for earthing the network.
Dd0Industry without neutralIf one unit of a bank of three single-phase transformers fails, it can keep running in open delta (V-V) with 57.7 % of the power.
Yd and Dy for rectifiers12-pulse rectifiersTwo secondaries 30° apart (one in star and one in delta) cancel the 5th and 7th harmonics.

The neutral loading percentages are usual indicative values; the manufacturer gives those of each transformer.

6. Parallel operation

To connect two or more three-phase transformers in parallel, HV to HV and LV to LV, these conditions must be met:

  1. Same voltage ratio, within 0.5 %. Otherwise a current circulates between them even with no load.
  2. Same clock number or a compatible one (see below). Otherwise the LV voltages are out of phase and there is a short circuit.
  3. Similar short-circuit voltages \(u_{k}\), within 10 % of each other, so that the load is shared according to each one's rating.
  4. Ratings not too different: no more than 3 to 1.
  5. Same phase sequence and same frequency: 2U to 2U, 2V to 2V and 2W to 2W.

Load sharing

Each transformer takes a share of the load proportional to its rating divided by its short-circuit voltage:

\[ S_i = S \cdot \frac{S_{n,i}/u_{k,i}}{\sum_j S_{n,j}/u_{k,j}} \]
Example. T1 of 630 kVA with \(u_{k} = 4\) % and T2 of 400 kVA with \(u_{k} = 4.5\) %, for a 1000 kVA load: \(630/4 = 157.5\) and \(400/4.5 = 88.9\), 246.4 in total. T1 carries \(1000 \cdot 157.5/246.4 = 639\) kVA (101 %, slightly overloaded) and T2, 361 kVA (90 %). Without overloading either, the pair delivers \(630 \cdot 246.4/157.5 = 986\) kVA, not 1030: the one with the lower \(u_{k}\) reaches its rating first.

Circulating current

If the ratios differ, a current circulates between the two transformers that only produces heat. With equal ratings, as a percentage of rated current:

\[ i_c \approx \frac{\Delta u}{u_{k,1} + u_{k,2}} \]
Example. Two 630 kVA units with \(u_{k} = 4\) % and a 0.5 % difference in no-load voltage (a different tap, for instance): \(i_c = 0.5/8 = 6.25\) % of rated, about 57 A on the 400 V side, with no load connected at all.

Compatible clock numbers

With the neutrals joined, the voltage between two corresponding terminals of transformers with a phase difference \(\delta\) is:

\[ U_d = 2\,U_f\,\sin\frac{\delta}{2} \]

With 230 V phase-to-neutral, 30° of difference (Dyn11 with Yyn0) gives 119 V and 180° (Yy0 with Yy6), 460 V. Before closing the paralleling breaker, measure with a voltmeter between each pair of corresponding terminals: it must read almost 0 V. The phase sequence is checked with a phase rotation meter. The single-phase case is in connecting transformers in parallel.

7. How to check the vector group with a voltmeter

When the nameplate cannot be read or it is unclear how a rewound transformer was connected, the clock number can be checked without special instruments:

  1. Join terminal 1U to 2U with a lead.
  2. Supply the HV side with a low, known three-phase voltage, for example 400 V from the mains, with the LV side open.
  3. Measure the voltages between 2V and 1V, 2V and 1W, 2W and 1V, and 2W and 1W.
  4. Compare them with those of the explorer in section 4 for the group it should be, using the nameplate voltages and the test voltage.

Each group gives a different set of voltages. If they do not match, try other clock numbers in the explorer until one fits. The voltmeter must read low voltages well, because the LV ones are small: with 400 V on a 20,000 / 420 V transformer, the LV side gives 8.4 V.

Related: transformer fundamentals · transformer analysis · single-phase transformers in parallel · delta-star transformation · harmonics