Terminal box, star-delta starting and comparison with other starting methods
A three-phase motor has three phases, and each phase is a circuit with two ends: U1–U2, V1–V2 and W1–W2 (IEC 60034-8 marking). With those six ends there are two ways to build the three-phase system:
\(U_L\) and \(I_L\) are the line voltage and current; \(U_f\) and \(I_f\), those of each winding phase. If each phase receives its design voltage, the motor delivers the same power in both connections, \(P = \sqrt{3}\,U_L\,I_L\cos\varphi\,\eta\): the only thing that changes is the supply voltage it needs.
The nameplate gives two voltages, for example 230/400 V Δ/Y. The lower one is the voltage each phase can take: the motor is connected in delta to a supply of the lower voltage and in star to a supply of the higher voltage (which is \(\sqrt{3}\) times the lower one). The nameplate current is also given twice, and the higher value belongs to delta.
| Nameplate | 230 V supply | 400 V supply | 690 V supply |
|---|---|---|---|
| 230/400 V | Delta | Star | Not suitable |
| 400/690 V | Not suitable (too little voltage) | Delta (allows Y-Δ starting) | Star |
| 400 V Δ (single voltage) | Not suitable | Delta | Not suitable |
In the Americas, 220, 380, 440 and 460 V supplies at 60 Hz are common, with 220/380 V nameplates (star-delta, like the ones above) or 220/440 V, which are dual-voltage motors with split windings and 9 or 12 leads: they are explained in the guide to dual-voltage motors.
The terminals are laid out on purpose: W2, U2 and V2 on the top row and U1, V1 and W1 below. With three identical links, star is made by joining the top row horizontally and delta with three vertical links, which join exactly U1–W2, V1–U2 and W1–V2. To reverse the direction of rotation, simply swap two supply lines, in either connection.
Getting it wrong has very different consequences depending on the mistake. A 230/400 V motor connected in delta to 400 V gets \(\sqrt{3}\) times its voltage on each phase: the iron saturates, the current soars and, if the protection does not trip, the winding burns out quickly. The opposite mistake, a 400/690 V motor connected in star to 400 V, is less obvious: each phase gets 231 V, torque drops to one third and the motor overheats as soon as it is loaded. This is what happens when a star-delta starter stays in star because of a faulty timer or delta contactor.
Started direct on line, a squirrel-cage motor draws 5 to 8 times its rated current. Star-delta starting reduces this without any special equipment: the motor starts connected in star and, once it has picked up speed, it is switched to delta, its running connection. During starting each phase receives \(U/\sqrt{3}\) instead of \(U\), which reduces the line current and the torque to one third:
\(Z\) is the impedance of each phase at standstill. The current drops to one third because in star each phase gets less voltage and, in addition, the line current is no longer \(\sqrt{3}\) times the phase current. Torque drops by the same ratio because it is proportional to the square of the voltage.
A 15 kW, 400/690 V, 28 A motor with \(I_a/I_n = 7\) and \(M_a/M_n = 2.2\), on a 400 V supply. Direct on line it would start with about \(7\cdot 28 = 196\ \text{A}\) and \(2.2\) times its rated torque. In star, with about \(196/3 \approx 65\ \text{A}\) (2.3 times rated current) and \(2.2/3 \approx 0.73\) times its rated torque. If the machine needs more torque than that to start, the motor will not accelerate in star.
Two conditions are needed:
KM1, KM2, F1 and the six motor cables carry the phase current, not the line current: \(I_n/\sqrt{3} \approx 0.58\,I_n\). This is why the overload relay is set to \(0.58\,I_n\) and the line and delta contactors are chosen for that current; the star contactor only works during starting and one rated for about \(I_n/3\) is enough (indicative values: switchgear manufacturers publish selection tables for each power rating). If the overload relay were placed upstream of the split, in the supply line, it would be set to \(I_n\).
The change should be made when the motor is close to its rated speed and the current in star has already fallen. If it is done too early, starting in delta is almost the same as direct-on-line starting; if it takes too long with a heavy load, the motor overheats. A timer of a few seconds is usual, adjusted by measuring the current with a clamp meter during starting.
During the changeover the motor is disconnected for an instant (open transition). It keeps turning and generates a voltage that, when delta is connected, may be out of phase with the supply: the result is a brief current and torque peak which, in large machines, can approach the direct-on-line one. To avoid it, there are closed-transition starters, with a fourth contactor and resistors that keep the motor energised during the change.
| Method | Starting current | Starting torque | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct on line | 5 to 8 · In | 100 % of DOL | The simplest; limited by the supply capacity |
| Star-delta | ≈ 1/3 of DOL | ≈ 33 % | 6-terminal motor in Δ at supply voltage; peak at changeover |
| Part winding | ≈ 60–70 % of DOL | ≈ 45–50 % | Suitable motors only; closed transition with two contactors |
| Autotransformer (65 % tap) | ≈ 42 % of DOL | ≈ 42 % | 50, 65 and 80 % taps; bulky and expensive |
| Stator resistors (65 % voltage) | ≈ 65 % of DOL | ≈ 42 % | Wastes energy in the resistors |
| Soft starter | 2 to 4 · In, adjustable | Reduced, ∝ U² | Voltage ramp and soft stop |
| Variable frequency drive | ≈ 1 to 1.5 · In | Up to 150 % of rated | Also controls speed; the most expensive |
Indicative values for squirrel-cage motors; actual values depend on the motor design and the starter settings.