EN

Boucherot's theorem

Conservation of active and reactive power: total power of an installation, power factor and current

1. Statement

In a sinusoidal AC circuit, the total active power is the sum of the active powers of all the elements, and the total reactive power is the algebraic sum of the reactive powers, regardless of how they are connected (in series, in parallel or mixed). The apparent power, on the other hand, is not added: it is obtained at the end from the other two.

\[ P = \sum P_k \]\[ Q = \sum Q_k \]\[ S = \sqrt{P^2 + Q^2} \neq \sum S_k \]
\[ \cos\varphi = \frac{P}{S} \]\[ \overline{S} = P + jQ = \sum \overline{S}_k \]

It is named after Paul Boucherot (1869–1943), a French engineer who stated it at the end of the 19th century while studying AC distribution. In complex form it says that complex power is conserved: the power delivered by the sources equals the power absorbed by the loads.

2. Sign convention

ElementPQFormulas
Resistor\(I^2R > 0\)0\(P = V I\)
Inductor (inductive)0\(+\,I^2X_L\)\(Q_L = V^2 / X_L\)
Capacitor (capacitive)0\(-\,I^2X_C\)\(Q_C = -V^2 / X_C\)
Load with inductive \(\cos\varphi\)\(P\)\(+\,P\tan\varphi\)Motors, transformers, reactors
Load with capacitive \(\cos\varphi\)\(P\)\(-\,P\tan\varphi\)Electronic power supplies with filters, long cables at no load

The reactive power of inductors and that of capacitors have opposite signs: they compensate each other. That is why a capacitor bank reduces the reactive power drawn from the grid without changing the active power, which is the basis of reactive power compensation.

3. Why apparent power is not added

Each apparent power is the magnitude of a complex number \(\overline{S}_k = P_k + jQ_k\). Magnitudes can only be added if all the vectors have the same angle, that is, if all the loads have the same power factor. As soon as resistive, inductive and capacitive loads are mixed, \(\sum S_k\) is larger than the real apparent power and oversizes the transformer, the cables and the protective devices.

The correct way is the total power triangle: the legs (P and Q) are added and the hypotenuse is calculated at the end.

4. Steps to apply it

  1. For each load, obtain \(P_k\) (nameplate data or \(I^2R\)) and \(Q_k = P_k \tan\varphi_k\), with a + sign if it is inductive and − if it is capacitive.
  2. Add all the active powers and all the reactive powers, including those of the line resistances and reactances if the powers at the supply point are wanted.
  3. Calculate \(S = \sqrt{P^2 + Q^2}\) and \(\cos\varphi = P/S\).
  4. Obtain the current: \(I = S / V\) in single-phase and \(I = S / (\sqrt{3}\,V_L)\) in three-phase.
Example 1: three-phase installation at 400 V

A workshop has a 15 kW motor with \(\cos\varphi = 0.82\), 6 kW heating elements and 4 kW of lighting with \(\cos\varphi = 0.9\) (inductive), plus an 8 kvar capacitor bank.

LoadP (kW)Q (kvar)S (kVA)
Motor15\(15 \tan(\arccos 0.82) = 10.47\)18.29
Heaters606
Lighting4\(4 \tan(\arccos 0.9) = 1.94\)4.44
Capacitors0−88
Total254.41Arithmetic sum: 36.74 (wrong)
\[ S = \sqrt{25^2 + 4.41^2} = 25.39\ \text{kVA} \]\[ \cos\varphi = \frac{25}{25.39} = 0.985 \]\[ I = \frac{25\,390}{\sqrt{3}\cdot 400} = 36.6\ \text{A} \]

Without the bank, \(Q = 12.41\) kvar, \(S = 27.91\) kVA, \(\cos\varphi = 0.896\) and the current would be 40.3 A. Adding the apparent powers would have given 36.74 kVA: 45 % more than the real value.

Example 2: series RLC circuit

A circuit with \(R = 10\,\Omega\), \(X_L = 20\,\Omega\) and \(X_C = 12\,\Omega\) in series is connected to 230 V. The impedance is \(Z = \sqrt{10^2 + (20 - 12)^2} = 12.81\,\Omega\) and the current \(I = 230/12.81 = 17.96\) A.

\[ P = I^2R = 3226\ \text{W} \]\[ Q = I^2X_L - I^2X_C = 6451 - 3871 = 2580\ \text{var} \]
\[ S = \sqrt{3226^2 + 2580^2} = 4131\ \text{VA} = 230 \cdot 17.96\ \checkmark \]

The inductor and the capacitor exchange 3871 var with each other; the grid only supplies the difference. With the RLC circuit tool you can check it with other values.

5. Total power calculator

Supply
V
Loads
LoadP (kW)cos φTypeQ (kvar)S (kVA)
kvar
0 if there is none

6. Applications

7. Precautions

Related: Tellegen's theorem (power conservation in any network) · three-phase power measurement