EN

Magnetic circuit

Air gap, saturation and hysteresis: why one millimetre of air counts for more than all the iron

A coil on an iron core forms a magnetic circuit. The coil's ampere-turns drive a flux through the core, just as a voltage drives a current through an electric circuit. The difference is that iron is not linear: above a certain flux density it saturates and stops carrying flux easily. And a one-millimetre air gap is enough for the coil to need many more ampere-turns.

Hopkinson's law

It is Ohm's law for the magnetic circuit. The magnetomotive force comes from the coil, the flux plays the role of current and the reluctance that of resistance:

\[ N\,I = \Phi\,\mathcal{R} \qquad \mathcal{R} = \frac{l}{\mu_0\,\mu_r\,A} \]

With an air gap of length g, the two reluctances are in series, like two resistors:

\[ N\,I = H_{Fe}\,l_{Fe} + \frac{B}{\mu_0}\,g \]

The first term is what the iron "uses up" and the second what the air uses up. In the iron, H comes from the material's B-H curve, which is not a straight line.

Simulator: core with coil and air gap

How the ampere-turns are shared

Material B-H curveAir-gap lineOperating point

The air gap is drawn exaggerated. Flux fringing at the gap is ignored; in practice it increases the gap's effective area a little. The B-H curves are approximate.

Things to try

Why the air gap rules

The relative permeability of good electrical steel is several thousand. That means 1 mm of air has the same reluctance as several metres of steel. In a core with a 30 cm path and a 0.5 mm gap, the air can take most of the ampere-turns.

Example

1 T across 0.5 mm of air needs \( H\,g = \frac{1}{4\pi\cdot 10^{-7}} \cdot 0.0005 \approx 400 \) ampere-turns. The 30 cm of steel, at about 110 A/m for 1 T, needs only 33. With 200 turns that is 2.2 A instead of 0.17 A.

Many workshop facts follow from this:

Saturation

Below the knee of the curve, iron multiplies the flux with little effort. Above it, every extra tesla costs a great many ampere-turns. Machines are designed close to the knee because that makes good use of the iron, so they have little margin:

If you are going to change the voltage, frequency or turns of a winding, see how to modify a winding without changing the flux density.

Hysteresis and no-load current

When a coil is fed with a sinusoidal voltage, what is imposed is the flux: \( E = 4.44\,f\,N\,\Phi_{max} \). The flux is sinusoidal and the current is whatever is needed to create it. While the iron is not saturated, the current is nearly sinusoidal. Near saturation, the current becomes peaky. Also, when the field falls the iron does not return along the same path: that is hysteresis.

Flux density B (sinusoidal, imposed by the voltage)Magnetising current, proportional to H

Formulas

QuantityFormula
Flux\( \Phi = B\,A \)
Reluctance\( \mathcal{R} = l / (\mu_0 \mu_r A) \)
Inductance\( L = N^2 / \mathcal{R} = N\,\Phi / I \)
Stored energy (linear)\( W = \tfrac{1}{2} L I^2 \)
EMF with sinusoidal voltage\( E = 4.44\, f\, N\, B_{max} A \)

The corkscrew rule gives the direction of the flux from the direction of the current, and Ampère's law is the basis of the equation \( N I = \sum H\,l \).