EN

Protective devices

From lead wire to the solid-state breaker: what each one does and why it was replaced

As soon as electricity was distributed there were fires and burnt cables too. Each device in this guide answers a limit of the previous one: from the piece of lead that melts to the breaker that cuts off in microseconds.

If you find an installation with fuse wire, do not modify it yourself or fit a thicker wire or a coin: that removes the protection and can start a fire. Have it inspected by a licensed electrician.

Timeline

Dates are approximate, because each technique took years to spread:

PeriodDeviceWhat it brought
Around 1880Lead fuse wireThe first protection for lighting networks, such as Edison's.
Late 19th c.Open breakers with arcing hornsReusable devices, but with arcs in the open air.
Around 1900Oil circuit breakersOil extinguishes and insulates the arc: opens up medium and high voltage.
Early 20th c.Cartridge fuses and electromechanical relaysEnclosed sand-filled fuse; induction disc with inverse time.
1924Hugo Stotz's miniature circuit breakerResets without replacing anything: the principle of today's device.
Mid-20th c.Air blast and moulded-case breakerMore power without oil that can burn.
1950sSF₆A gas that recovers insulation very quickly. First uses in 1953-1956.
1960sModern residual current device and vacuumDalziel presents the GFCI in 1961; vacuum takes over medium voltage.
1980sDigital relays and electronic trip unitsAdjustable curves, fault recording and communication.
2013AFDD arc-fault detector (IEC 62606)Detects arcs in damaged cables that do not trip a circuit breaker.
TodaySolid state and alternatives to SF₆Cut-off in microseconds without an arc; lower-climate-impact gases and vacuum.

The dates of the circuit breaker, SF₆ and the GFCI have been checked against public sources; the others are historical approximations.

Fuse wire: "the leads"

It is the simplest idea: a piece of conductor that heats up before the installation and melts. In Spain people still say "han saltado los plomos" (the leads have blown). In the late 19th century W. H. Preece studied the current that melts a wire and gave a rule that is still quoted:

\[ I = a\,d^{3/2} \]

With d in mm, a is 80 for copper and 10.8 for lead. A 1 mm lead wire melts at about 11 A; a copper wire of the same diameter, at about 80 A. That is why fitting copper wire is so dangerous: the fuse now withstands more than the cable it should protect.

Its defects explain what came next: the melting current varies with the mounting, oxidation and temperature; it can be replaced with a thicker one; molten metal spatters, and at high current the wire keeps conducting through the arc. You can see its curve in the curves tool.

From the cartridge to today's fuse

The solution was to enclose the element in a ceramic or glass body filled with quartz sand. On melting, the sand absorbs the heat and turns the metal vapour into an insulating material. Notches in the element create several arcs in series, and it cuts off before the first peak: the fuse is a natural limiter.

It is still not outdated. It has a very high breaking capacity in little space, needs no maintenance and has no mechanisms that can seize. Its defects are that it has to be replaced and that it may blow on one phase only, leaving a three-phase motor on two phases. Even so, gG and aM remain common at main incomers and on motors.

Circuit breakers, moulded cases and relays

The circuit breaker combines two mechanisms: a bimetal, which bends slowly and protects against overloads, and a coil with a core, which trips instantly on a short circuit. Hugo Stotz's 1924 patent made it small and resettable. Moulded-case and air circuit breakers apply the same idea to larger currents, with more and more adjustment.

Relays did the same separately: a relay measures and another device breaks. The induction disc type, similar to an old energy meter, naturally gives an inverse time. Its digital heir, the IED, performs all the functions in a single unit, stores fault oscillograms and communicates over protocols such as IEC 61850.

Extinguishing the arc at medium and high voltage

At higher voltages the problem is the arc. Oil was tried first; it extinguishes well but can burn and needs maintenance. Then came compressed-air blast, very noisy and with large installations, and later SF₆, with great dielectric strength.

Vacuum took over medium voltage: the arc has no gas to ionise, goes out at the first zero and the interrupters last a long time. SF₆, widely used at high voltage, is a potent greenhouse gas, so the trend is to replace it with alternative mixtures or vacuum.

Other risks, other devices

A short circuit is not the only danger. The residual current device compares outgoing and returning current to detect leaks of a few milliamperes, which a circuit breaker would never see. The surge protector diverts peaks from lightning and switching. The AFDD recognises the current waveform of an arc in a damaged cable. In motors, PTC sensors measure winding temperature and motor protection breakers combine thermal and magnetic functions in one device.

What each one protects against

DeviceProtects againstDoes not protect against
gG fuseOverload and short circuitLow-current earth leakage, loss of a phase.
aM fuseShort circuitOverload.
Circuit breakerOverload and short circuitContact with people, small leaks.
RCD without overcurrent protectionEarth leakageOverload and phase-to-phase short circuit.
Thermal relayMotor overload and, often, phase lossShort circuit.
AFDDSeries and parallel arcs in cablesOverloads and short circuits: it complements the other protections.
Surge protectorBrief voltage peaksOvercurrents and sustained overvoltages.

The protection of an installation is always a combination. To set it properly, first calculate the current at each point and then check the curves.

Yesterday's devices in today's installation

Continue with: Protection curves, Breaking capacity and opening and Short circuit in DC and AC.