EN

Protection curves

From lead wire to the electronic relay: compare two devices on the same chart

1. Compare two devices

Example
Upstream device
Downstream device
Point in the installation
A
mm²

Band of each device: the thin line shows up to where it does not trip and the thick line when it has already cut off. Dashed purple line: thermal limit of the cable. Red line: Ik.

How to read a curve

It is a logarithmic chart: current along the bottom, time on the left. Each device has a band, not a line, because manufacturers and standards allow tolerances. To the left of the band it does not trip, to the right it has already cut off and, inside, either can happen. The sloping part is the overload protection, which takes longer the lower the current; the vertical step is the instantaneous protection.

What is drawn for each device

DeviceModel pointsUsed for
Circuit breaker B, C, DNo trip at 1.13·In and trip within 1 h at 1.45·In; the middle section is typical. Magnetic: 3-5, 5-10 and 10-20·In.Domestic and commercial circuits. C is the most general; D, for heavy starting.
gG fuseConventional 1.25 and 1.6·In, with indicative middle sections.General use, with high breaking capacity and limitation.
aM fuseShort circuit only, from about 4-6·In.Motors, together with a thermal relay.
Moulded caseThermal between 1.05 and 1.3·Ir; adjustable magnetic ±20 %.Industrial distribution.
LSI relayL: tr at 6·Ir, with constant I²t. S: fixed delay. I: instantaneous.Main incomers: allows selectivity to be adjusted.
Thermal relayNo trip at 1.05·Ie; trip at 1.2·Ie. Class: maximum time at 7.2·Ie.Motor overload. It does not break short circuits.
Fuse wirePreece for the fusing current; adiabatic heating for short times.Old installations. Only for understanding how they worked.
\[ I_{\text{Preece}} = a\,d^{3/2} \qquad t \approx \frac{K\,S^2}{I^2 - I_{\text{Preece}}^2} \]

For fuse wire, d is the diameter in mm, S the cross-section and a = 80 for copper, 12.8 for tin and 10.8 for lead, according to Preece's classic values. The constant K comes from the properties of each metal, without the latent heat of fusion. The band is deliberately wide: a real wire depends on how it is mounted, on its oxidation and on the surrounding air.

Selectivity

Two devices are selective if, for a downstream fault, only the nearest one trips. On the chart, the lower band must stay to the left of the upper one without touching it up to the Ik at that point. The tool looks for the first current at which they touch. A classic rule for gG fuses is to leave a rating 1.6 times higher upstream, and between circuit breakers a delay is usually needed.

Limits: this is not a manufacturer's curve

The bands come from the points set by EN 60898, IEC 60269, IEC 60947-2 and IEC 60947-4-1, quoted without checking against the official text, and are joined with indicative sections. They are for learning and comparing. Below 10-20 ms the curve no longer says anything reliable: real selectivity is decided by the devices' I²t and the manufacturers' tables. For a project, always use their curves.

See also: Protective devices, past and present, Breaking capacity and opening and Short-circuit current and breaking capacity.